Showing posts with label Welfare of veterans and their widows. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Welfare of veterans and their widows. Show all posts

Sunday, September 5, 2010

SOME USEFUL INFORMATION for Veterans and their Widows.

Dear Veterans,Regards.
Find below ......
SOME USEFUL INFORMATION

Some useful information from Indian Air Force Website.
Besides the additional pension, certain other new provisions of VI CPC and other key provisions which can affect the entitlement to pension/family pensionary benefits are as follows:-
(a) The minimum pension/family pension wef 01.01.06 is Rs 3500/- plus DR.
(b) The rates for 100% disability element of pension are revised to Rs 5880/-pm for commissioned officers and honorary commissioned officers wef 01-01-06. Similarly it is revised to Rs 4300/- and 3510/- pm for warranted ranks (JWO,WO & MWO) and other ranks respectively. For disability, which is less than 100%, proportionate reduction in the amount will be done. The rates of constant attendant allowance have been increased to Rs 3000/-pm wef 01-01-06 irrespective of rank. This will further increase by 25% every time, when the DR on the revised Pay Band goes up to 50%.
(c) Broad banding of disability pension for invalidated officers is permitted, since
V CPC i.e. 01-01-1996. This broad banding is done to the nearest higher figure at
50%, 75% and 100%. Earlier this facility was not extended to pre 01-01-1996
pensioners. Now, wef 01-07-2009, this facility is extended to all pre 01-01-1996
disability pensioners who were invalidated out of service.
(d) Disability pensioners are exempted from income tax on their complete pension
which includes service element and disability element.
(e) Enhanced family pension (50% of last pay) was payable for seven years from
the date of death of the officer. After VI CPC, enhanced rate of family pension for post retirement death remains unchanged at seven years; however, for in-service death of an officer, the enhanced rate of family pension is now extended to 10 years from earlier period of 07 years. For those cases where enhanced rate of family pension for seven years has been completed before 01 Jan 06, there is no change. However, if seven years of enhanced pension is falling due on 01 Jan 06 or beyond (for service death cases only), then case is to be taken up through this office (Dte of PP&R) for extending the enhanced family pension by three years (total 10 yrs) through issue of Corr PPO by CDA. PBOR should take up case on similar lines with AFRO.
(f) Widows in receipt of Special family Pension (SFP) were permitted to
draw their family pension even after remarriage after V CPC i.e. 01-01- 1996. SFP
is primarily given for death which is attributable to service. Widows, who were
remarried before 01-01-1996, were not eligible for the same. Now widows in receipt of SFP who were remarried before 01-01-1996 and whose family pension was stopped are eligible for grant of SFP wef 20-01-2009. The widows who are eligible should apply to this office in the case of officers and to AFRO for cases related to PBOR.
(g) Widows in receipt of ordinary family pension (OFP) were not eligible for family pension after remarriage. However, as an exception a child less widow after VI CPC, is eligible for ordinary family pension after remarriage, subject to fulfillment of certain laid down income criteria. The widows who are eligible should apply to this office in case of officers and to AFRO for cases of PBOR.
(h) Widows whose husbands were in receipt of gallantry awards (PVC, Ashok
chakra, MVC, Kirti Chakra, Vir Chakra, Shaurya Chakra, VM (Gallantry), are entitled to the same monetary allowance (rates doubled wef 14 May 08) after the death of their husband. In addition, they are exempt from income tax on their full pension.
(j) The recipients of Gallantry award winners of Chakra series (PVC, MVC, Vr C,
Ashok Chakra, Kirti Chakra and Shourya Chakra) and their widows are entitled for complementary card passes along with a companion from the Indian Railways, for free travel in first class/ second AC. The passes will be issued by the office of
Divisional Railway Manager and Headquarters office of the Railways on receipt of an application on plain paper. Widows will be required to additionally submit copy of death certificate and non remarriage certificate from a gazetted officer.
(k) Handicapped children (not capable of earning livelihood) and Unmarried /
divorced / widow daughter are eligible for family pension subject to fulfillment of
income criteria and Audit verification. For Endorsement of the name of handicapped child in the PPO, an officer can apply during his life time. However, unmarried /divorced / widow daughter can apply for family pension only if she is unmarried/remains divorced at the time of demise of her last surviving parent (father or mother).Her name will not be annotated in the PPO during parent’s life time.
Note:
1. Knowledge is power. Without appropriate knowledge on the provisions of VI CPC, no meaningful action can be initiated by the pre 01-01- 06 pensioners to rectify their incorrect pension fixation.

Veteran Prabhjot Singh Chhatwal PLS Retd.
President,Ex-Soldiers,Sailors and Airmen association (Regd.)
3-Guru Ram Dass Nagar , Tripuri Road, Patiala,Punjab-
147 004.
Mob. 098554-09128, Tele-fax 0175-5000896.

Wednesday, May 26, 2010

Discrepancies in payment of Defence Pension: Veteran Prabhjot Singh Chhatwal PLS Retd.

DEAR VETERANS- ATTENTION PLEASE.

Ex-Soldiers, Sailors and Airmen Association has detected during, a survey held in last month, that a no. of defence pensioners, particularly family pensioners, are not being paid correct amount of pension and there are glaring discrepancies in some cases.
In one such case, Smt. Rajinder Kaur, War Widow of Flt. Lt. Gurbax Singh, a General Duty Pilot and War Hero of 1965- War fame, was noticed of being paid a pension of Rs. 3500/- only without element of D.A. i.e. less than an Ordinary Pension of a Sepoy's widow instead of Liberalized Pension of Flt. Lt. (War Causality). Her husband was killed in action on 9th September, 1965 during the war with Pakistan.
This case involved the negligencey on the part of Pension Sanctioning Authority i.e. PCDA (Pension, Allahabad) and then Pension Disbursing Authority i.e. State Bank of Patiala, Dharampura Br. Patiala which failed to pay her D.A. on the meager pension, erroneously, granted to her by PCDA (Pension), for the last about four decades.
The Association immediately took up the case of payment of D.A. on present pension, with P.D.A. i.e. SBOP, Patiala and got the error rectified, to a great relief resulting in to payment of huge amount of arrear to the widow.
The case of enhanced pension to the war widow, Rajinder Kaur, is being taken up by the Association with PCDA, (Pension) Allahabad, along with another case of Stoppage of Service Pension of to Chief Petty Officer, Jaswant Singh, whose pension was stopped by Treasury Officer, Faridkot, the then Pension Disbursing Authority, in year 1974. The Ex-servicemen, who is above 70 years old now, drew his pension for one year and went abroad and returned after ten years to find his pension stopped. He requested his PDA to get his pension restored as per the law but got no response. He then tried his best for about twenty years by writing to various authorities related with the pension but of no avail. During this period his PDA i.e. Treasury Officer, Faridkot misplaced his pension record and washed his hands by making an entry in the pension register that his pension papers were dispatched to PSB. Since then the ex-serviceman is running from pillar to post and writing every one who could help him.
Now he has approached this Association for help to get his pension restored. The Association is planning to take up both these cases with the Pension Adalat going to be held in the month of July, 2010 at Pathankot and to write to the concerned authorities in due course.
Earlier the organization helped Late. Sub.Sher Singh of Patiala and Late. Smt. Ranjit Kaur of Amloh to get them the correct amount of pansion. Late. Sub. Sher Singh of State Forces was being paid Sepoy's pension since long. He got relief through the Association, though belated i.e. a month prior to his death. Similarly Smt. Ranjit Kaur, widow of Sub. Gurdial Singh, was also being paid the pension of Sepoy's widow which was got enhanced by the Association, that too at the fag end of her life, about two months before her death.
The Association is planning to conduct a detailed survey during the next six months in Punjab through its block level functionaries and submit a consolidated report to Director, (Pension), Deptt. of Ex-Servicemen Welfare, Govt. of India, New Delhi.


Veteran Prabhjot Singh Chhatwal PLS Retd.
President
Ex. Soldiers, Sailors and Airmen Association,
# 3, Guru Ram Dass Nagar, Patiala,
Punjab, India 147 004.
Mob: 98554-09128, Tele-Fax: 0175-5000896

Friday, February 19, 2010

AN APPEAL AND A REQUEST TO VETERANS

AN APPEAL AND A REQUEST TO
VETERANS
Dear veterans,
Regards. Ex Soldiers, Sailors and Airmen Association
(ESSAA), is not an Association which has been formed
under ordinary circumstances. It has come up as a
result of gross injustice done to veterans of the rank of
Sub. Maj. and below by 6th Central Pay Commission
and at the same time, most un-caring attitude exhibited
by the serving Chiefs as well as retired Senior officers
still holding their sway in the bureaucratic set up of the
govt. towards those who serve or served under them.
1. Where as the Pay commission has dumped the soldiers,

up to the rank of Hav. and below, in Pay Band PB-1(along
with Class IV) and JCOs in Pay Band PB-II (along with
certain Class III employees of Centre Govt.) without
paying slightest attention to the fact that Hav. and Nk.
are Senior and Junior Non-Commissioned Officers and
JCOs. are Junior Commissioned Officers, no serving
Chief as well as Senior Retd. Officer came to their rescue
when certain organizations of veterans in Punjab raised
the demand of placing soldiers of the rank of Hav. in Pay
Band PB-II and Sub. Maj. in Pay Band PB-III as if Pay
Band PB-III is reserved for Commissioned Officers only.
At the same time when the demand of placing Lt. Col.
in Pay Band PB-IV surfaced, serving Chiefs as well as the
Senior Retd. Officers rallied around this demand and
supported it till the same was agreed to by the Govt.
2. ESSAA was born out of the frustration caused

among the veterans as a result of this discriminatory
attitude of the officers, both serving as well as retired,
towards them.
3. An Appeal and a Request.
a. As per rules, money received by way of Life

Membership Fees, will be invested as ‘Fixed Deposit’ in
the Bank. Only the Annual Membership Fee and interest
that will accrue on this ‘Fixed Deposit’ will be utilized
for funding various expenditure & activities of ESSAA,
viz. organizing Meetings of members, Press Conferences
and veteran’s Rallies etc. Since the amount that accrues
as interest will be very less and will not suffice to fund
ESSAA activities, this appeal is being made to veterans
to join ESSAA in large no. and donate as much as your
pocket allows for this good cause. Though a few of our
Veterans have been very kind & gracious enough to
to donate money to ESSAA for its activitie, not much
is available in our kitty to carry on our work smoothly.
b. Money is always required to fund every movement &

ESSAA is no exception.. Money to sustain ESSAA will
have to come from Veterans (Hony. Offrs and below)
themselves. Senior veterans will spend the money and
energy to hamper your efforts as one Maj. has gone to
Court with a plea that he gets less pension than a
Sub. Maj. is drawing more pension than him in his
neighborhood.
c The ESSAA is committed to fight for the rights

of Veterans (HONY. OFFRs and below).Our foremost
demand is that Govt. should grant enough pension to
enable us to live honorably and grant the Modified
Parity in Pension at the earliest and subsequently
change the Pay Band for Hav.and Sub. Major.
d. Our next demand is grant of two pensions to the

widow whose husband drew two pensions during his
life time.
e. We further demand guaranteed employment up to

the age 60 years like civilian employees.
To fight for such demands of veterans (Hony. Offrs. and

below, this organization has been formed under the able
guidance of one of the most experienced and able ,
Veteran Prabhjot Singh Chhatwal PLS Retd. which has
now spread to whole of India and many state units
have come up. As such, we appeal to you all to join the
organization in large number to achieve your aim
Vet. B.S. Sohi Vet. S.C.Sharma Vet. Malkit Singh

IAF IND. NAVY IND. ARMY
Vice President Gen. Secy Asst Secy.
Vet. M.S.Anand
IAF
Finance Secy.

Sunday, February 7, 2010

Directory of Ex-Servicemen :Veteran Prabhjot Singh Chhatwal PLS Retd.

Directory of Ex-Servicemen

Ludhiana, February 6.In order to extend best services to
ex-servicemen, the District Sainik Welfare Office has decided
to compile a directory of all ex-servicemen residing in the
district to keep a record that will help the department.Giving
details, newly-joined District Sainik Welfare Officer Col
Harvinder Pal Singh said, “We expect that around 40,000
ex-servicemen are residing in Ludhiana alone. If we have all
record pertaining to these former defence servicemen, we will
be able to help them.”Urging all former defence officials to
give their present address and contact numbers to the District
Sainik Welfare Office, Ludhiana, Col Harvinder said, “The
directory will be helpful in forming a network that could be
used at the time of crisis and whenever their experiences and
services are required.”The information could be conveyed at
94178-22874, 98769-71230 and 0161-2741066.The project will
also be available in a digital format and will help the
department have better interaction with ex-servicemen and
their families.

Tuesday, December 29, 2009

Good News for Pre-2006 Pensioners (Veterans): Veteran Prabhjot Singh Chhatwal PLS Retd.

Dear Veterans,
Regards. There is a good news for pre-2006

pensioners (Veterans) ahead.

As per my personal discussion with Sh. Harbans Singh,

Director Pension, Department of Ex-Servicemen
Welfare, Ministry of Defence, the Committee
(constituted on the instructions from Prime Minister),
has submitted its report to Ministry of Defence and
orders relating to Modified Parity in Pension for
Pre-2006 Defence Pensioner are likely to be issued
soon. But he was not committed to give any
information about the date of issuance of notification.
Pre- 2006 Pensioners are also likely to get disability
pension on percentage basis like Post- 2006
Pensioners. Pre-2006 Hony. N/Subs are also going to
get pension of regular N/Subs. like Post-2006 Hony.
N/Subs. We should be very clear about the fact that
no Govt. can afford to grant One Rank One Pension
as was demanded in joint Memorandum submitted
by a group of organizations on 14th Oct. 2009.
Have a Good day and move forward to a Grand

New Year '2010'.

Veteran Prabhjot Singh Chhatwal PLS Retd.
Mob:98554 - 09128 Tele-fax: 0175 - 5000896.

Saturday, December 26, 2009

Veterans resent govt filing appeals in favourable cases: Veteran Prabhjot Singh Chhatwal PLS Retd.

Dear Veterans,
Regards.Find below the news appeared
in today's Tribune for your information
Veteran Prabhjot Singh Chhatwal PLS Retd.
Mob:098554-09128. Tele-fax: 0175-5000896

Veterans resent govt filing appeals in favourable cases
:
Tribune News Service
Chandigarh, December 25The Army’s continuation of filing
appeals against High Court orders granting relief to disabled
ex-servicemen in apparent violation of the settled legal
position has caused resentment among the service community.
In a letter written to the Ministry of Defence as well as the

Ministry of Law, ex-servicemen have contended that the
Department of Pensions of the Defence Ministry and the
Personnel Services Directorate at the Army Headquarters
are making it a point to file appeals against almost all
decisions of courts rendered in favour of disabled soldiers.
The said departments, the letter states continues to file

appeals against the decisions of single benches before
Division Benches and of division benches before the
Supreme Court, even when the law is well settled by
the apex court.
Highlighting some specific examples, the letter contends

that the ministry has been filing appeals by brushing
under the carpet, the legal opinion of the office of the
Solicitor General and verdicts of the Supreme Court.
A noting sheet obtained under the RTI Act on one such
issue showed that the Ministry of Defence ignored
legal opinion of the Solicitor General.
The letter contends that more than the logic behind

the decisions, it is the ego of the mighty government
machinery which swings into action once a verdict
is pronounced in favour of a petitioner. Further,
some departments tend to file frivolous, misleading
and unethical appeals not only leading to a burden
on the judiciary but also forcing a waste on the
exchequer and man-hours of public servants.
Ex-servicemen say that unnecessary litigation against

disabled soldiers not only causes extreme financial
and psychological distress to them but is also against
the overall spirit of the policy of the government in
this regard and the stated position of the Law Ministry.

Wednesday, December 23, 2009

What is' Annexure- IV' ? Attention:Pre-2006 Pensioners including widows :Veteran Prabhjot Singh Chhatwal PLS Retd.

Dear Veterans,
Regards.Please go through the following and
exercise your right to know your entitlement
of pension.Please pass it on to other pensioners
also.
Veteran Prabhjot Singh Chhatwal PLS Retd.
Mob.09554-09128,Tele-Fax.0175-5000896.

Wednesday, December 23, 2009
What is ‘Annexure-IV’ ?
(Attention : Pre 01-01-2006 Pensioners)
A joint public notice by the Ministry of Defence
and the Ministry of Finance was published yesterday
in many newspapers.The said notice called upon banks
to provide ‘Annexure-IV’ to pre-01-01-2006 pensioners
so that the correctness of pension and arrears could be
ascertained.So what is ‘Annexure-IV’ ?‘Annexure-IV’ is
a form which was annexed with Govt of India letter
dated 11 Nov 2008 dealing with the revision of pension
of pre-2006 pensioners. This annexure was supposed
to be filled up and returned by the Pension Disbursing
Agencies (PDAs), that is, banks, DPDOs etc to the office
of PCDA(P) with a copy to the pensioner concerned.
The said Annexure contains all details as to how
pension has been calculated and the arrears thereon.
The public notice was necessitated by the situation
that banks have not calculated pension of pre-06
pensioners correctly in many cases and neither have
they returned Annexure-IV duly filled to the
pensioners or the office of PCDA(P).All pensioners
have a right to demand a copy of Annexure-IV from
their PDAs. Please exercise it.The said Annexure may
download it by clicking here.
Maj. Navdeep.

Tuesday, December 22, 2009

Notice to Ex-Servicemen Pensioners : Veteran Prabhjot Singh Chhatwal PLS Retd.

Dear Veterans,

The following notice has been published by Deptt. of

Ex-ServicemenWelfare, Ministry of Defence in various

news papers for the informationof Ex-Servimen Pensioners.

Please read yourself and pass the information to other

veterans to act upon this .

Veteran Prabhjot Singh Chhatwal PLS Retd.

GOVERNMENT OF INDIADEPTT OF EX-SERVICEMEN

WELFARE (MINISTRY OF DEFENCE)DEPTT OF FINANCIAL

SERVICES(MINISTRY OF FINANCE)

NOTICE TO ALL EX-SERVICEMEN PENSIONERS .

The pension of pre 1-1-2006 ex-servicemen in implementation

of the recent recommendations of the 6th CPC has to be revised

as per MOD’s letter dated 11-11-2008 which is also available

on the website www.cgda.nic.in, www.pcdapension.nic.in

and www.mod.nic.inAnnexure IV to MOD’s aforementioned

letter which has 16 columns isrequired to be completed by

all Pension Disbursing Authorities (PDAs)and given to the

pensioners. In Column 12 of the Annexure IV details

of computation of revised pension/ family pension are to

be indicated while in Column 13 arrears of pension/ family

pension are to be mentioned by the Banks.Deptt of Financial

Services have issued clear instructions to the Chief Executives

pf all public sector banks to complete the task of revision of

pension expeditiously and supply Annexure-IV duly filled in

to the Ex-serviceman pensioners vide their letter

F. no. 2/2/2008-BO.II dated 25th September 2009 and

F. No. 2/2/2008-BO.II dated 15th December 2009.Therefore,

the ex-servicemen pensioners should obtain a copy of Annexure

IV from the respective Pension Disbursing banks. The concerned

Banks are also requested to supply Annexure IV duly completed

to all ESM pensioners so that correctness of entitlement of

pension can be ascertained by them.This notice is being issued

by the department of Financial Srvices (Ministry of Finance)

and the Department of Ex-servicemen Welfare (Ministry of

Defence) in public interest.

Wednesday, December 2, 2009

Software pangs for defense pensioners: Veteran Prabhjot Singh Chhatwal PLS Retd.





Chandigarh, December 1- Some Defence Pension Disbursing

Offices (DPDOs) are refusing to release pension in accordance

with new scales till the time they are provided new computer

programmes by the Controller General of Defence Accounts

(CGDA).
Departmental reply to a query under the RTI, which was

produced during hearing of a case before the Chandigarh Bench

of the Armed Forces Tribunal (AFT), states that the new pension

would be fixed on receipt of revised computerised programme

from the CGDA as no manual revisions by the DPDO office is

authorised.
While majority of veterans drawing their pension through banks

are getting their benefits as per the revised scale post-Sixth Pay

Commission implementation, those dependent on DPDOs are still

getting lesser pension.
Taking up the case of an 80-year old widow, Swaran Kaur, the AFT

has ordered that her family pension be revised within two months.

The AFT also directed a representative of the Controller of Defence

Accounts to be present before it on the next date of hearing to explain

the inordinate delay in revising pensions.
Swaran Kaur’s husband, Santok Singh, a World War-II veteran had

died in December 2006. He was getting pension in accordance with

Fifth Pay Commission rates. In November 2008, Presidential sanction

was accorded for raising the scales of pension in accordance with the

Sixth Pay Commission.
Under revised rates, the pension of similarly placed individuals was

raised from Rs 1,275 per month to Rs 3,500 per month.
Between November 2008 to August 2009, the petitioner and her son

visit the DPDO office regularly, but the rates of pension in her case are

not revised nor is she paid arrears.
In September 2009, the Principal Controller of Defence Accounts also

writes to the DPDO concerned, asking him to act in accordance with the

revised scales and make the payment to the widow. However, her

pension still remained unrevised.


Veteran Prabhjot Singh Chhatwal PLS Retd.

President,

Indian Ex-services League,Punjab & Chandigarh.

Mob.098554-09128,Tele-Fax 0175-5000896.

Friday, November 27, 2009

Questions likely to be raised by S.Navjot Singh Sidhu, Member Parliament, in Lok Sabha in a couple of days : Veteran Prabhjot Singh Chhatwal PLS Retd.

Deare Veterans,
S. Navjot Singh Sidhu,Hon’ble Member of Parliament
(A-7, M.S. Flats, B.K.S. Marg, New Delhi-110001), is likely
to raise the following questions, relating to Veterans, in
Lok Sabha,in a couple of days or so. Let us hope for the best.

As per the unofficial information pouring in the Hq. of this
organisation,veterans may hope to get some authentic
information regarding Improved pension during the first
week of Decembe,2009..

QUESTIONS LIKELY TO BE RAISED BY

MEMBER PARLIAMENT ON MILITARY

PENSIONS (OROP)

1. More than 22000 medals have been returned to the President
by the Military Veterans so far – the last lot being the return of
2000 medals on 25th Oct 2009. It is a known fact that a medal is
very cherished and coveted part of a soldier’s life, both while in
service and after retirement. That the veterans have been
driven to such an extreme step shows the disillusionment and
frustration at the apathy of the Govt towards them.

2. The
soldiers have been agitating since quite some time to
restore their dignity and pride which have been drastically
eroded by the recommendations and implementation of
6th Pay Commission by the Govt which has shown a total
disregard to the ethos, rank structure and, esprit de corps of
the Defence Forces. This will contribute to a large extent in
shaking the very foundation over which the Defence Forces of
the country stand. History will not forgive, the perpetrators
of this – the Pay Commission and the Govt. They have
intentionally or unintentionally demoralized the ex - soldiers
and by default the serving personnel as well.

3. I implore upon the Govt to take immediate remedial
measures to restore the confidence of the Military by seriously
going into their grievances before some tragic incident occurs.
Defence Forces of India function on hierarchical principle
without which the military can not function. The 6th CPC has
ruthlessly demolished their system. I want the Hon’ble Raksha
Mantri to reply on the following issues as starred questions.

Q 1. Why has the Govt ie PM, RM, FM mislead the nation both
in Parliament and outside that OROP had been implemented.
This is a blatant lie to confuse and mislead the Parliament
and the Nation, when actually on the ground no action has
been taken in this regard ?

Q 2. (a) An old pensioner (Pre 96) Sepoy with 17 years of

service gets a pension of Rs 3500/-per month only where as
a Sepoy retiring after 2006 with same years of service gets
a Pension of Rs 7045/- per month. Like wise all
Ex- servicemen of all ranks who retired prior to 01 Jan 06
will draw much less pension as compared to their counter
parts retiring after 01 Jan 2006 This is totally unjust,
arbitrator, illegal and happens only in our Country.
Will the worthy RM explain the rational of such
differentials?

(b) A Major General pre 2006 retiree get far less pension

than A Lt Col, (who is four ranks junior) who retired after
01-01-06. Likewise , other senior rank officers ie Brig, Col,
Lt Col, Maj, Capt, Lt, PBORs who are pre 2006 retirees get l
ess pension than their counterparts who retired after
01-01-06. This is a weird situation which is also a blatant
violation of Article 14 and fundamental rights of the
constitution. A senior rank officer must never get less
pension than his junior rank officer irrespective of thedate
of retirement. The very functioning of the Army Rank
structure is being adversely affected since the present
serving personnel are the future retirees. Will the worthy
RM explain the rational of this serious anomaly?

(c) There is far too large a gap --- of Rs 11600 --- between
Major and Lt Col. Similarly, too large a gap has been
created between the pensions of Major General and Lt Gen
i.e Rs 9800/- The pensions of Lt Col, Col, Brig and Major
General have been kept in a rather too narrow a range ie
Rs 25700 – Rs 26700/-, a gap of only Rs 1000. The length
of service and level of responsibility held have not been
given due weigatage. Between Col and Maj Gen, the
difference in pension is only Rs 650/-. The anomaly is too
glaring. There should be sufficient gap, between the
pensions of successive ranks and there should be no large
variations within a particular rank. Why the pensions
of Defence Pensioners structured so illogically. Will the
RM explain please?

(d) While implementing the Supreme Court judgment in
the case of Maj Gens, the Govt has accepted the concept of
granting the same pension to pre 96 and post 96 retirees
with same rank and same service the plea made by
Maj Gens when 5th Pay Commission was implemented.
In the same way, the Govt should have applied the same
concept in the case of pre 01 Jan 2006 and Post 01 Jan 2006
retirees of all ranks. Why the same has not been done?

(e) Three Assured Carrier Progressions (ACP) concept has

been accepted as 6th CPC award. But the same has not
been applied to the past pensioners. The past pensioners
should also be given the benefit of ACP by notionally
applying the concept to them and their pensions fixed
accordingly. Why the same has not been done?

(f) The Hon’ble PM on 15 Aug 09 in his speech at the Red

Fort announced enhancement of pensions of Junior
Commissioned Officers of Army and their equivalent in
Navy and Air Force and Other Ranks of Army, Navy and
Air Force. However, Govt orders of implementation of
enhanced pensions have not yet been issued.
What are the reasons for the delay?

Q 3. Why in the last 62 year the status of Defence Personnel

viz a viz their civil counterparts has been constantly eroded.
A few examples:-

o In 1947 highest Police Officer in a State was equivalent to

a Lt Col. However after 6th CPC he has been placed even
ahead of Lt Gen.

o A joint Secretary level officer was equal to a Major. However

, now he is equated with major General.

o A Jawan who handles all the technical equipment and
sacrifices the best period of his life in the most inhospitable
terrain and conditions and is on duty 24 hrs 365 days a year
and who has voluntarily surrendered his fundamental rights
has been equated with a peon in the Civil Govt.

4. Not to compare but to bring it to the notice of this august
house the respect which other countries give to their soldiers.
I wish to highlight some excerpts from the speech President
Obama gave at veterans of Foreign War Convention on
August 17, 2009

Quote

“And our nation owes these Americans ...and all who have

given their lives- a profound debt of gratitude… And as always,
the thoughts and prayers of every American are with those who
make the ultimate sacrifice in our defense….. We fulfill our
responsibility to our veterans as they return to civilian life…
Whether you’ve left the service in 2009 or 1949, we will fulfill
our responsibility to deliver the benefits and care that you earned
….These are commitments that we make to the patriots who serve…
from the day they enlist to the day that they are laid to rest.”

Unquote


5. Lastly a nation which does not show gratitude and respect to i

ts soldiers will do so at their own peril.

Veteran Prabhjot Singh Chhatwal PLS Retd.
President,
Indian Ex-Services League, Punjab & Chandigarh.
Mob.098554-09128, Tele-Fax 0175-5000896.

Thursday, November 26, 2009

FLYING INTO HOPE- Indian Defence Forces need the Healing Touch of President,their Supereme Commander ;Vet.Prabhjot Singfh Chhatwal PLS Retd.

Dear Veteran,
Regards. Find below an article by a celebrated veteran(Air Marshal) B.D.Jayal. I must remind you that this article has translated the aspirations of all of veterans into words. One of our veterans, Thomas Manimala,has already expressed same on the C'Box of this blog yesterday. Let us hope for the best in days to come.

Veteran Prabhjot Singh Chhatwal PLS Retd.
President,
Indian Ex-services League ,Punjab & Chandigarh.
Mob. 098554-09128,Tele-Fax. 91-175-5000896.



FLYING INTO HOPE - The Indian military
needs the healing touch of the President
Brijesh D. Jayal


By the time this article is published, the president of India
and supreme commander of the armed forces will have
bestowed a singular honour on the armed forces by having
flown in a Sukhoi combat aircraft. To anyone other than jet
fighter pilots just the preparation for such a flight is
forbidding, quite apart from the flight itself. The flying gear,
the anti-gravitation suit, the survival kit, the heavy crash helmet
and the stifling oxygen mask are but some of the tedious add-ons.
To then get strapped into an ejector seat and be firmly locked
into a cramped cockpit with little freedom to move leaves the
uninitiated flustered. That the president did all this must surely
display a determination on her part, not just to be known
as the supreme commander of the armed forces of India,
but to be seen as one. To mingle at the operational end of her
command and expose herself to the accompanying risks will,
therefore, be perceived by every soldier, sailor, airman and veteran
as a great symbol of hope for the future of the institution of
the armed forces of India. A future that in recent times has looked
progressively fragile.

Ceremonially, the president is adequately exposed to the armed forces

of which she is the supreme commander. She must regularly see the
President’s Bodyguard at Rashtrapati Bhavan, an elite unit of the
Indian army tasked with her security and ceremonial duties. Her
military secretariat consists of a three-star rank military secretary,
carefully chosen, as also three aides de camp from each of the three
wings of the armed forces. Also, the three chiefs and a select few
seniormost commanders from each service are honoured to be
designated as honorary ADCs to the president. This entitles them
to add the suffix, ADC, proudly to their decorations.

At one level, the immaculate turn-out, the glittering medals and

crisp demeanour of the military that she sees around her must
assure her that she commands the best that the nation has to offer.
At another, she will have seen, perhaps for the first time,
the operational end of a force and been suitably impressed that the
nation remains secure in such hands. When she chooses to sail a
ship of the Indian navy or visit our army colleagues defending some
of the cruellest terrains in the country, her confidence will be only
further enhanced.

Upon return to the heady air of the Rashtrapati Bhavan and buoyed
by the experience of her day in the field, she may be tempted to call in
her military secretary and wonder at the deeper significance of medals
adorning his chest. She will be pleasantly surprised to learn that these
pieces of metal and ribbon that look merely decorative represent a deep
emotional attachment in the wearer. Each signifies service rendered
through sweat and blood. Those for distinguished service and gallantry
are conferred by the president herself and each has a story to tell.
Stories that are passed on and etched in institutional memory of
operational units such that they inspire successive generations of men
and women to draw sustenance from them and not be found wanting
were the moment of reckoning ever to come.

The military secretary may be emboldened to delve deeper and explain
that the design of each medal has significance, as have the colours of the
accompanying ribbons. Red, the colour of blood and fire, stands for courage
and bravery. Saffron for self-effacement and dedicated service. White for faith,
glory and purity. Blue for devotion to duty and sacrifice, and so on. Above all,
each medal has etched on its rim the rank, name and number of the individual
on whom it is conferred. A medal, therefore, to a soldier is far more than the
service and sacrifice that he or she has rendered through thick and thin;
it is a personal recognition of this sacrifice by the nation. This makes it an
invaluable part of a soldier’s life in and out of uniform.

Recognizing that the constitutional role of the supreme commander is a
ceremonial one, the president may well ask her military secretary what
the ordinary soldier would expect from their supreme commander.
The secretary could explain that the credo of the armed forces is:
“The safety, honour and welfare of your country comes first, always and
every time; the honour, welfare and comfort of the men you command
come next; your own ease comfort and safety come last, always and every
time.” It is this code by which the armed forces conduct themselves and
judge their success or failure. It is also the one by which they judge higher
national leaderships.

Having got thus far and finding the president in a mood to learn more
about the strange ethos of a body of men and women, of whom she is the
supreme commander, the military secretary may be emboldened to
reveal to her that at that very moment there are stored in some obscure
corner of the Rashtrapati Bhavan hundreds of such medals that have been
neatly labelled and packed by their proud recipients, but returned
as a symbol of solemn and dignified protest at being perceived to have
been let down by the very nation that had bestowed the honour on them.
More such medals keep coming at regular intervals.

He may explain this unfortunate chapter as having its roots in the
anomalies of the sixth pay commission and the denial of the frequently
promised “one rank one pension” principle. Since knocking on various
doors evoked no response, many veterans held silent gatherings at
various memorials across the cities and towns. These gatherings were
in tribute to their fallen colleagues and also intended to convey their
pain and anguish at the neglect and apathy in addressing various
issues concerning the welfare of veterans. The surrendering of medals
was the next step in this inglorious first in the annals of free India’s
military history and one that a sensitive leadership should have made
every effort to nip in the bud, but chose to ignore instead. As indeed
it continues to do.

While the veteran community was one with the cause, the above means
of redressal followed by some succeeded in dividing the veteran
community itself, pitching senior and distinguished veterans, including
commanders, on either side of the divide. Clearly, here was another
dubious first, this time in the history of veteran solidarity.

He may even explain that when the unprecedented step of surrendering
their valued medals to their supreme commander was contemplated,
rather than facilitate an audience with the president to assuage hurt
sentiments and show due courtesy to senior veterans, some lower
functionary in the president’s secretariat received their valued medals.
Clearly the dignity which steered these veterans through their years of
sacrifice was missing at the doors of their erstwhile supreme commander.
A wound that could have been healed by an audience with the president
had callously been allowed to deepen, as more and more medals were
sought to be returned.

The military secretary may venture to suggest that since today’s forces
are tomorrow’s veterans, this state of affairs is deeply distressing to the
entire institution of the armed forces and needs the supreme
commander’s healing touch. He may add that this is the first time in the
history of the Indian republic that the supreme commander is actually
being called upon to exercise her authority in furtherance of her
welfare responsibilities.

Even as the president mulls over this burdensome background, she may
begin to wonder why, as supreme commander, she was not expected to
lay a wreath at the Amar Jawan Jyoti on the occasion of the annual
Republic Day military parade. Further, she may wonder why
Amar Jawan Jyoti, which symbolizes an eternal Indian soldier in whose
memory the flame burns, was the shadow of India Gate, which is a fitting
memorial that the British built in memory of our soldiers who died
fighting their wars — not ours. Where indeed was the national war
memorial commemorating all those who have laid down their lives
fighting India’s wars and the proposal regarding which has been shuttling
up and down the corridors of national governance for decades? These
disturbing questions would now weigh heavily on her presidential
responsibilities.
If the symbolic gesture of stepping into the cockpit of a combat aircraft
and getting a feel of what the defence forces are doing to keep this nation
secure generates some of the emotions and welfare concerns that afflict
the institution of our defence forces and their veterans, then the hope
generated by this symbolic event may well translate into reality —
that of a more active role of the supreme commander in the realm of
welfare of the men and women she commands.

The president has the distinction of being the first woman to hold this
exalted position. Let her choose to be the first to exercise her obligations
towards the welfare of those under her supreme command.

The author is a retired Air Marshal of the Indian Air Force